The 5 Best Custom Photo Puzzle Companies in 2021

Custom Photo Jigsaw Puzzle with Little Girl
Source Shutterstock/In Green

Family members who enjoy putting together puzzles will appreciate some of their favorite photos on a personalized puzzle. The best photo printing companies have various puzzle options to choose from and print each photo using high-resolution formatting. They are flexible in the types of pictures they accept and at the same time provide excellent customer service.

A personalized jigsaw puzzle makes a perfect gift for the whole family to remember a special holiday or occasion. A personalized photo puzzle can also create family fun as everyone contributes to putting the puzzle together. Our search helped us uncover the five best photo puzzle companies for everything from family collage puzzles or fun kids puzzles.

Types of Custom Puzzles

There are literally dozens of different types of photo puzzles to choose from, including:

  • Wooden Jigsaw Puzzles
  • Magnetic Puzzles
  • Plastic Jigsaw Photo Puzzles
  • Double-sided Jigsaw Puzzles
  • ‘Endless’ puzzles

Read on to learn which are the best companies to choose from to order a custom jigsaw puzzle to give as gifts for the upcoming holidays or simply spend hours of fun with family and friends.

Our Product Selections

1. Best Custom Puzzle Overall – Pictorem Print Company


  • Price – ~$35 (Was $58) (17×12 inches, 315 pieces) – Our score: 9/10
  • Finish – Gloss – Our score: 9/10
  • Variety – Fully customizable – Our score: 9/10
  • Customer Service – Excellent – Our score: 9/10

About Pictorem Puzzle Prints

For high-quality puzzles, including a personalized picture puzzle, Pictorem is top-notch. Pictorem offers personalized puzzles in a variety of different sizes with either artwork or a favorite image printed on a photo puzzle. These custom jigsaw puzzles can showcase favorite memories and make an excellent personalized gift for Christmas, a wedding anniversary, or as a gift, the whole family can enjoy.

Each puzzle is printed using 300 dpi (PPI) on a firm backing with a high gloss finish. What’s more, if you aren’t a professional photographer and your photo needs professional editing, Pictorem offers image optimization and picture enhancement.

Your very own photo puzzle can either arrive assembled without a box or disassembled in a plain cardboard box or an attractive metal tin. The estimated delivery date is approximately two weeks from the date of purchase.

Sizes start from 25 pieces, shaped like a heart up to 1,000 pieces.


  • Free shipping within Canada and the US
  • Includes a volume discount with a Pro account
  • They have an ICC profile
  • Offers a 30-day satisfaction guarantee


  • Does not deliver outside of the US or Canada
  • Boxes are extra

2. Best Photo Puzzles – Portrait Puzzles Photo Gift


  • Price – ~$29.99 (16×20 inches, 300 pieces) – Our score: 9/10
  • Finish – Semi-matte – Our score: 8/10
  • Variety – Small variety – Our score: 8/10
  • Customer Service – Good – Our score:8/10

About Portrait Puzzles

Make your own jigsaw puzzle with Portrait Puzzles to create a personalized gift for that special occasion. Portrait puzzles offer eight different puzzles from 30 to 1,000 pieces, including 16 postcard puzzles that can be great for kids. Creating puzzles for family and children is fun and can keep memorable moments alive.

Ordering a photo puzzle is straightforward and easy. Simply upload your favorite images, ensuring that it’s a high-quality image, choose the size puzzle you’d like, the type of box, or if you want it to arrive assembled. In addition, photos can be mailed in or scanned if no digital file is available.

Each personalized picture puzzle can add text of up to 15 words at no extra charge. Only a single image can be placed on each jigsaw puzzle. If you aren’t happy with the final product, the company will reimburse you.


  • Made in the USA
  • Next day shipping
  • Puzzle box is included in the price
  • Provides gift certificates


  • Assembled puzzles are an additional price
  • Cannot preview the puzzle before it’s cut

3. Best Picture Puzzles – Printique Personalized Puzzle


  • Price – ~$23 (11×14 inches, 252 pieces) – Our score: 9/10
  • Finish – Gloss – Our score: 8/10
  • Variety – Small variety – Our score: 8/10
  • Customer Service – Good – Our score: 8/10

About Printique Photo Puzzles

Picture puzzles make great gifts, and Printique offers personalized puzzles for both kids and adults. Kids’ puzzles range from 30 to 56 pieces, and puzzles for adults are between 252 to 1,014 pieces. Your custom jigsaw puzzle arrives in a sturdy black box, unassembled with the photo image printed on the cover.

Multiple photos are not supported when creating your picture puzzle, but the handy editor tool allows users to edit images before finalizing the picture.

Small puzzle pieces can pose a choking hazard to young children, so keep this in mind when gifting a picture puzzle to a family with small kids.


  • Has the option to create kids and adults puzzles
  • A photo or kids artwork can be printed on the puzzle


  • Shipping is included on orders over $100
  • Doesn’t ship internationally

4. Best Photo Jigsaw Puzzles – Create Jigsaw Puzzles

Create Jigsaw Puzzles Photo Puzzle

  • Price – ~$17.99 (12×16.5 inches) – Our score: 8/10
  • Finish – Four different finishes – Our score: 9/10
  • Variety – Wide variety – Our score: 9/10
  • Customer Service – Good – Our score: 8/10

About Create Jigsaw Puzzles

Create Jigsaw Puzzles has everything under the sun to make a puzzle in just about every shape or size, from wood, plastic, magnets, or traditional puzzles even to puzzle jewelry. To make your own puzzle, simply upload one or multiple photos, choose from dozens of design possibilities, choose a gloss or matte finish or gloss/matte linen finish, and 11 box or bags options.

Additional choices include different piece shapes from tubes, a tree, a collage, 2-sided puzzle pieces, a guest book puzzle, and a coloring photo puzzle for kids. In addition, their number-shaped puzzle would be a great kids’ birthday present or to celebrate an upcoming wedding anniversary. Unique puzzle pieces include a lenticular design, 3D, cork, and acrylic.

Personalized puzzles are printed on professional or premium boards with a textured or traditional surface. Family members can add text to the photos for more personalized gifts and create lasting memories.


  • Multiple finishes available to make your own custom puzzle
  • Two framing options provided
  • Bulk discounts
  • Offers the widest variety of custom photo puzzles on our list
  • Additional gift options include accessories such as crayons and cards


  • Does not ship internationally

5. Best Collage Puzzle – Photo Puzzles


  • Price – ~$19.99 (Was $39.99) (11×14 inches, 250 pieces) – Our score: 9/10
  • Finish – Matte or gloss – Our score: 8/10
  • Customizable – Good variety – Our score: 9/10
  • Customer Service – Good – Our score: 8/10

About Photo Puzzles

To make a custom puzzle with a family collage is easy and fun with Collage Photo Puzzles. Make a puzzle with multiple photos and customized text to give as a present for that special day with different designs to choose from. Businesses can also create a puzzle with their company logo for marketing purposes.

There are two different puzzle types for kids and adults. To design your own puzzle, simply upload a high-quality image, choose a finish, design type, and, lastly, the size of the puzzle. Sizes range from a 30 piece puzzle to 1,000 pieces.


  • Has a large variety of different types of collages
  • Is currently offering a 60% discount
  • The storage box is included
  • Ships internationally


  • Standard orders arrive within 10 business days


We hope you found our guide to the best custom photo companies helpful. We’ve covered the different types of puzzle options available and have shared our recommendations in various contexts.

We’ve discussed how you can choose the best custom photo companies with different puzzle design options. Lastly, we’ve combined our recommendations to create fun custom photo puzzles for every budget.

Thanks for reading; we hope our suggestions help you choose the best-personalized picture puzzle for gift-giving this holiday season.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *